Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH by Robert C. O'Brien



I'm sorry to report that I accidentally chose a "four books in one" monster of a P.D. James novel to kick off the year, and it is taking me forever to finish it.  I didn't realize the heft of the book because I bought it on my Kindle, and I didn't pay attention to the number of pages.  I did, however, manage to read 1971 Newbery Medal Winner Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH by Robert C. O'Brien to my kids last week. 

The story is about a widowed mouse named Mrs. Frisby who must find a way to move her house (a cinder block) from one corner of the garden to a safer one. Her frail, thoughtful son, Timothy, has recently recovered from a bout of pneumonia and will not survive if he is exposed to the cold, early-summer nights.  She seeks help from a colony of elusive rats who harbor a secret that involves her late husband, Jonathon. She learns that the rats have undergone chemical experiments at the National Institute of Mental Health, resulting in their being over a thousand times more intelligent than natural rats.  With the help of Nicodemus, the leader of the NIMH rat colony, she learns the truth about her husband's early life and uncovers a strange, cautionary tale about science and ethical limits. 

The book was everything quality children's literature should be:  funny, interesting, cozy, nerve-wracking, and thought-provoking.  And all of this without being a thinly-veiled Disturbing-Story-For-Grown-Ups told in a Kindergarten-Teacher-Voice.  I hate those kind of books. 

The book is 233 pages with the occasional pen-and-ink illustration.  The target age for the book was 8-12, but I read it to my 6, 7, and 9 year olds, and they were all rapt.  Oh--and if you've seen the movie, don't skip the book.  As usual, the book is densely packed with philosophical discussions and character development that the movie omits.  Also, the movie throws in a bunch of bite-your-knuckle plot twists that don't happen in the book. In the words of my nine-year-old, "How dare they change the plot?  After all Robert's hard work?"  (She and Robert are tight, it would appear).  The biggest offense in her mind?  That the movie changes Mrs. Frisby's name to Mrs. Brisby, and that Jenner is portrayed as a Stone-Cold-Killa, which he isn't in real life.  (Real Life=The Book.  But I don't have to tell you people that).

Q for you:  What other children's books-turned-movies have you read?  Tell me in the comment section, and if you've reviewed any children's books-turned-movies, Mr. Linky-it-up!





BookBlips: vote it up!



29 comments:

fakesteph said...

I reviewed the Percy Jackson movie... it was not favorable, so I'm not sure if I'll link it up. Haha. But I LOVED the adaptation of A Series of Unfortunate Events. I thought it got the tone perfect. I had to be around 17 when it came out. I was sitting next to a little kid who didn't quite get that the movie is so serious it's funny and I was reprimanded for laughing because "this is important later on".

buybooksonline24x7 said...

Buy Books Online 24x7. Visit http://www.buybooksonline24x7.com

Avid Reader said...

I read this as a kid and it has remained one of my favorite books. I loved the characters and I'm with your kids, how dar they change the plot for the movie! Great review.

Rachel said...

Your review was great, too, Avid. Love your blog!

Shelly said...

I love your blog! I followed yours do you think you could do the same? My url is bookiecutie.blogspot.com

Amy said...

I love your daughter's outrage at the movie industry's adaptation! I agree: how dare they!

Peter Combs said...

I absolutely loved this cartoon when I was a kid! Never realized that it was based on a book. I need to check it out. Thanks for the great review, always looking for something new to read.

Suzanne said...

I've always wanted to read this book! Thanks for a wonderful review and reminding me that even though there are no children in my household, a good bit of YA fantasy is a great escape!

Pluella said...

The Witches by Roald Dahl - it was my first ever book-read-then-movie and I read it again now - 10 yrs later and watched the movie as well!Back then I read Matilda as well, amazing as well... So long ago....ouf!

Pluella said...

The Witches by Roald Dahl - it was my first ever book-read-then-movie and I read it again now - 10 yrs later and watched the movie as well!Back then I read Matilda as well, amazing as well... So long ago....ouf!

Froggy said...

I have to agree with the Percy Jackson movie...they changed the movie all up and it really stunk. Same with the Twilight books IMHO...I know I might get backlash for that but the movies were a bit boring. I adore the books though

Froggy
Froggarita's Bookcase

Sharon said...

One of my favorites has to be The 101 Dalmatians by Dodi Smith. Loved that book, but have not reviewed it.

The Bumbles said...

I've always liked the Roald Dahl adaptions I've seen - and of course the books too!

There are so many books that I read as a child that now would be entirely new stories to me since I have forgotten the details completely - much like this one, or the Narnia series, or Bedknobs and Broomsticks, The Mouse & The Motorcycle, The Phantom Tollbooth, etc. etc. I would love to set aside some time to re-read them all.

Jill said...

My son was similarly upset when we went to see Voyage of the Dawn Treader after having read the book over the summer. I haven't read this one to my kids because my MIL tried to show them the movie and they got scared. That was a couple years ago so maybe we can try it again. I liked your review.

Ollie said...

I Loved this book!! When I was a little kid, my dad read this to me at night, but he always skipped the "scary" parts.

Hector Macdonald said...

Hi Rachel

I can't find an email address for you, so please forgive me intruding on your comment wall. I’d like to invite you to write about your favorite books at www.bookdrum.com, where you can add information, images, video, music and links to illustrate and explore the books.

Right now, we're running a $3500 Tournament and we'll be offering contract work to the best entries.

Best wishes

Hector Macdonald
Editor, Book Drum

Rose said...

So I thought I recognised the title, and as I read your review it sparked a whole set of shadowy memories - I must have read this as a kid, but forgotten it. I'm adding it to my library list...

Great review too, and I agree about the brilliance of some books written for kids when they're at the age to start getting into a bit of extra complexity.

booksforevermore said...

Oh I love this book! I also adore the Secret Garden and Chronicles of Narnia. as C S Lewis said, you do often enjoy childrens books more as an adult than as a child.

Rebecca said...

I love this children's books and I love your blog! I just became a follower...I'm a brand new book blogger and would love to have you follow my blog! Do you ever introduce or announce new book blogs on your blog? I would be really excited and grateful if you would consider doing so! :)

www.readingwithrebecca.blogspot.com

Alec said...

It's been a long time since I read this book. I remember a little of it from when I was a kid. All good memories.

Erin said...

This is one of my favorite children's books, and I continue to read it over and over. I've also read it to my eight-year-old son, and it is one of his favorites as well.

Ash said...

I loved Nimh when I was a kid!!

~ The Tuckerbag ~

Kristene Armstrong said...

I've heard this book is really good. But I haven't read it yet. Maybe I need to put it on my TBR pile. :)

Unknown said...

Your review was great, too, Avid. Love your blog

DulceMaria said...

I've always wanted to read this book!
I've always liked the Roald Dahl adaptions I've seen - and of course the books too!

debi said...

Just discovered your blog-love it-following it : )
One of my all time favorite "children's" books is "Watership Down". I have read and reread it and finally found it on audio which I downloaded to my Kindle.
If you aren't familiar with it the story is about a ragtaggle group of rabbits trying to start a new warren after one of the rabbits has a vision that their present one will be destroyed.
There is a movie,animated, but I didn't see it.

debi said...

I never saw the animated movie but heard mixed reviews about it. However, the book Watership Down is my all time favorite book. I've read it and listened to it on audio.
Also loved Mrs. Frisby and the rats of NIMH and the movie as well - but of course the book best! A book was written from his note called Z for Zachariah, a science fiction YA book.

http://debi-booktalk.blogspot.com/2011/11/watership-down.html

Susan Bennett said...

That cover is way cool.

diaryofadomesticgoddess said...

I read this book when I was bout 7-y-o and I LOVED it! I really must get hold of it again and reread it. :)